Dog bite claims in Broward are often treated as simple. The injury is obvious, the dog is identifiable, and Florida’s statute does not require proof that the dog had bitten before. But the statute that makes these claims straightforward also defines exactly what has to be shown, and the defences it allows turn on evidence that tends to disappear quickly.
What Florida law says
Section 767.04, F.S. — “Dog owner’s liability for damages to persons bitten” — makes the owner of a dog that bites a person liable for the damages, where the person is in a public place or lawfully on or in a public place or private property, including the owner’s property, regardless of the former viciousness of the dog or the owner’s knowledge of such viciousness.
The same section then sets out the points that most disputes are actually about:
- Lawful presence. A person is lawfully on private property when performing a duty imposed by state or federal law or by postal regulations, or when on the property on the express or implied invitation of the owner.
- Comparative negligence. If the bitten person’s own negligence was a proximate cause of the bite, the owner’s liability is reduced by the percentage that negligence contributed.
- The “Bad Dog” sign. The owner is not liable, except as to a person under the age of 6, or where damages are proximately caused by a negligent act or omission of the owner, if at the time of the injury the owner had displayed in a prominent place on the premises a sign that was easily readable and included the words “Bad Dog.”
- Other remedies remain. The remedy provided is cumulative to any other remedy under statute or common law.
Section 767.01, F.S. separately provides that owners of dogs are liable for damage done by their dogs to persons, domestic animals and livestock. Part II of chapter 767 addresses dangerous dogs: s. 767.11 defines a “dangerous dog,” and s. 767.12 (“Classification of dogs as dangerous; owner requirements; penalty”) sets out the classification process.
How these provisions apply to a particular bite is a question for your attorney. What follows is about the facts they depend on.
Who actually owns the dog
The statute speaks of the owner, and the person holding the leash or answering the door is not necessarily that person. A dog may belong to a tenant rather than the homeowner, to a relative who is visiting, to a roommate, or to someone who has since moved. Whether a landlord, a keeper or anyone else bears responsibility is a legal question; identifying who is who is a factual one, and it comes first.
- Who lives at the property, and who the dog lives with, established through public records and canvassing.
- Who owns the property, through county property appraiser records, and whether it is owner-occupied or rented.
- Licence and rabies tag information and the bite report, which may identify the person who claimed the dog.
- Neighbours who know whose dog it is, how long it has been there, and how it has behaved.
Apartments, condominiums and shared spaces
A large share of Broward lives in apartment complexes, condominiums and gated communities, and bites there raise their own factual questions. Was the bite in a unit, a hallway, a pool deck, a parking area or a dog park? Who controls that space — the unit owner, a tenant, an association or a management company? Were there earlier complaints about the same dog to the association or the management office, and were any rules about leashes or restricted breeds in place and enforced? Whether any of that creates responsibility beyond the dog’s owner is for your attorney to assess. Establishing exactly where it happened, who controls that area, and what complaints were already on file is the investigation, and association minutes, notices and neighbours’ recollections are where it usually starts.
Prior incidents and animal control records
Bites in most of Broward are reported to the Broward County Animal Care Division, and some cities run their own animal control — the City of Pompano Beach, for example, has its own Animal Control division. Which agency holds the records depends on where the bite happened. Under s. 767.12, an animal control authority investigates reported incidents involving a dog that may be dangerous, requires a sworn statement from anyone seeking to have a dog classified as dangerous, gives the owner written notice of any sufficient-cause finding, and offers a hearing.
Prior bite reports, complaints, warnings and any dangerous-dog proceedings involving the same animal or the same owner are central evidence, both on what the owner knew and on the owner’s own negligence. They are also records that have to be requested from the right agency, under the right name and address, which is where accurate identification of the owner and the dog pays off.
The scene and the sign
Because the “Bad Dog” defence depends on a sign being prominently displayed and easily readable at the time of the injury, the condition of the premises at that moment matters. A sign that appears after the incident, or one that was hidden behind a hedge, faded or posted where nobody would see it, is a factual question that photographs settle.
- Photograph the gate, fence, entrances and any signage, wide and close, with dates preserved in the original files.
- Document the fence and gate condition: gaps, broken latches, a gate left open.
- Record where the bite happened relative to the property line, the sidewalk and the entrance used.
- Note the age of the injured person. The sign defence does not apply to a child under 6.
Witnesses and what the injured person was doing
Comparative negligence is where the defence usually concentrates: the person reached over the fence, entered without invitation, provoked the dog, ignored a warning. Independent witnesses — neighbours, delivery drivers, passers-by — are the best answer either way, and they are much easier to find while the event is fresh. A witness who gave a name and phone number at the scene and then went silent is a locate problem. See how to locate a witness for a Broward County case.
Lawful presence deserves the same care. A mail carrier, a utility worker performing a legal duty, an invited guest and a contractor asked to come to the house are all in different positions from someone who walked through a closed gate, and the facts of the invitation need to be pinned down.
Identifying insurance, lawfully
Many dog bite claims are paid, if at all, through a homeowner’s or renter’s policy. An investigator’s role is to establish who owns the dog, who owns and occupies the property, and the correct names and addresses, so that counsel can put the right party and its carrier on notice. Insurance information itself comes through counsel and legal process, not through pretext or access to anyone’s private records.
The deadline
An action founded on negligence must be commenced within two years under s. 95.11(5)(a), F.S. Confirm with your attorney how limitations apply to your claim. The evidence deadlines — video, witness memory, the state of the gate and the sign — arrive long before that.
For both sides
We work these matters for injured people and their attorneys, and also for carriers and defence counsel. The investigation is the same either way: who owns the dog, where it happened, who was lawfully there, what the sign said and where it was, what the animal control file shows, and what the witnesses saw. See personal injury investigations and civil plaintiff investigations. The same principle runs through premises cases generally; see slip and fall investigations in Broward County.
If you or your child has just been bitten
- Get medical care first, and keep every record.
- Report the bite to animal control for the city or county where it happened.
- Photograph the injuries over time, the scene, the gate, the fence and any signage.
- Get the dog owner’s name and address, and contact details for every witness.
- Note doorbell and security cameras nearby, and ask that footage be kept.
- Do not give a recorded statement to an insurer before speaking to your attorney.
Broward Private Investigations is a licensed Florida investigative agency, and our investigators work throughout Broward County. Every matter is scoped and quoted per case. Call (954) 235-4955 or contact us for a confidential consultation. This article is general information, not legal advice — talk to your attorney about your situation.
Our licensed Broward County private investigators work from our Sunrise office across Fort Lauderdale, Hollywood, Pembroke Pines and the rest of the county; every engagement starts with a confidential consultation.
Broward Private Investigations