Most people assume that falling in a store settles the question of liability. In Florida it barely starts it. Section 768.0755(1), F.S. is explicit: if a person slips and falls on a transitory foreign substance in a business establishment, the injured person must prove that the business had actual or constructive knowledge of the dangerous condition and should have taken action to remedy it.
That single sentence is why so many otherwise genuine claims fail. The spill is cleaned, the shift ends, the footage overwrites, and three months later there is nothing left to prove with.
The two ways the statute lets you prove it
Section 768.0755(1) says constructive knowledge may be proven by circumstantial evidence showing that:
- (a) Time on the floor. The dangerous condition existed “for such a length of time that, in the exercise of ordinary care, the business establishment should have known of the condition.”
- (b) A recurring condition. The condition “occurred with regularity and was therefore foreseeable.”
Those are two completely different investigations. The first is about one spill and one clock. The second is about a pattern — a leaking cooler, a doorway that floods whenever it rains, a produce aisle that is wet every afternoon. A claim that cannot prove the clock can sometimes prove the pattern, and the pattern evidence is usually the evidence nobody went looking for.
Subsection (2) is worth knowing too: the statute “does not affect any common-law duty of care owed by a person or entity in possession or control of a business premises.” The knowledge requirement applies to transitory substances; it did not abolish everything else.
What an investigation actually looks for
- Video, and all of it. Not just the fall. The hour before it, to establish how long the substance was there and who walked past; and the minutes after, to capture the response. The before-footage is what proves element (a), and it is the part that is most often not preserved.
- The incident report. What the business wrote down at the time, who wrote it, who was notified, and what the written account says about the cause.
- Inspection and sweep logs. Many chains run documented floor sweeps. Either the log shows a sweep that did not catch the hazard, or it shows no sweep at all, or the log is missing. All three help.
- Maintenance and repair history. A work order on the same cooler, roof, drain, mat or door is element (b) in documentary form.
- Prior incidents at the location. Previous falls in the same area are the clearest evidence of a foreseeable, recurring condition.
- Witnesses. Customers who saw the spill before the fall, and employees who knew about it. Employees move on quickly; locating a former employee months later is a skip-trace job. See skip tracing.
- The scene, measured and photographed. Floor surface, slope, drainage, lighting, mat placement, warning cones, signage — documented before the location is remodelled or the mats are replaced.
- Weather and conditions for a rain-tracked entrance claim, matched to the time of the fall.
The two Florida rules that set the schedule
An action founded on negligence must be commenced within two years under s. 95.11(5)(a), F.S. And under s. 768.81(6), F.S. — “Greater percentage of fault” — a party found more than 50 percent at fault for his or her own harm may not recover any damages, other than in medical negligence actions.
In premises cases the defence works that second rule hard: you were looking at your phone, you were wearing the wrong shoes, the cone was right there. The counter is independent documentation of the condition and the sightlines, gathered while they still exist — not a recollection formed a year later.
Both sides of the same evidence
We work these cases for claimants and for carriers and defence counsel, and it is the same investigation either way: what was on the floor, how long it was there, who knew, what the records show, and whether it had happened before. A claim that the evidence supports is worth pursuing; one it does not is worth knowing about early. See insurance defence investigations and personal injury investigations.
If you have just fallen in a Broward store
- Report it before you leave and ask for the incident report number.
- Photograph the substance, the surrounding floor, your shoes and the whole area including any signage — wide shots as well as close-ups.
- Note the time, the camera positions you can see, and the names or descriptions of staff who responded.
- Get contact details for any customer who saw it. They will be impossible to find later.
- Seek medical attention and keep every record.
- Put the video preservation demand in writing quickly — this is normally counsel’s first letter.
Broward Private Investigations is a licensed Florida investigative agency serving Broward County and South Florida. Every matter is scoped and quoted individually. Call (954) 235-4955 or contact us for a confidential consultation.
Our licensed Broward County private investigators work from our Sunrise office across Fort Lauderdale, Hollywood, Pembroke Pines and the rest of the county; every engagement starts with a confidential consultation.
Broward Private Investigations